Paid Time Off Vs Vacation Days | What is The Difference Between Paid Time Off and Vacation?

Are you planning to make a time off policy? It is time to learn about paid time off vs vacation days. 

The basic difference between paid time off and vacation is that all vacations are paid, but not all paid time off are vacations. 

Criteria	Paid Time Off	Vacation
Definition	Can include urgent leave, personal work, sick days, etc.	Leisurely days off planned at least a month ahead
Payment	Paid	Paid
Planning	Usually unplanned	Planned at least a month ahead

A common practice among employers is allocating their time off policies at the beginning of their calendar year. On the other hand, some employers implement paid time off banks for the ease of their employees. 

Employers also execute accrued policies. This policy lets an employee earn their offs by working for days. 

There are certain examples of employers who provide the opportunity of unlimited time off. This capless policy is executed based on trust and work efficiency. 

There are numerous components involved in selecting the right paid time off policy and vacation policy for your company. 

• The first thing to consider is if you are going after traditional time offs, which have selective brackets for each category. 
• Or if you want to provide an open bank pool (where the employer has the least visibility). 
• Another factor to weigh in on is the accrual leave policy or providing gross time off at the beginning of the year. 
• Furthermore, an employer must also consider if they want to add the leftover leaves in the next year or not. 

Let’s discuss vacation and paid time off in detail.

What Is PTO (Paid Time Off)?

The days away from work the employer pays for are paid time off days or PTO. 

Companies can calculate PTOs on an hourly basis or day-wise. 

Paid time off days are sometimes classified into different categories, such as sickness, personal, public holidays, bereavement, emergency, vacation, etc. Employees can use their time off days as per the company policy. 

A good PTO policy ensures a healthy work-life balance, which in turn keeps the employee happy and interested in working with the organization in the long term. 

Paid time off is divided into three policies.

Paid Time Off Policies	Description
Traditional Leave Policy	Employers set the number of days for sick leave, vacation, personal days, and public holidays. HR can track why employees are taking time off, collect data, and plan policies. However, it can create more clerical work for the HR department.
PTO Bank Policy	Employees are given a lump sum of leave days, not divided into categories. They can use these days as needed without specifying the reason.
Unlimited PTO Policy	Employees can take as many days off as they want. However, effective time and work management are required. Approval from management and meeting work-related deadlines are necessary.

What Is Vacation Time?

Relaxing and rejuvenation is the requirement of every employee who works tirelessly. Hence, vacation time plays a part. 

It is when an employee takes a break from work and goes on a leisure trip without any salary deduction. This paid off time is mandatory in some companies, and employers encourage employees to avail themselves of their dedicated vacation days. 

Vacation time yields a boost in energy in the employee who returns to work with more dedication and focus. 

Most employers define the outline of vacation days at the beginning of the year. However, the number of vacation days may vary according to the position and years of employment. 

Moreover, some companies allow their staff to take vacation time at any time during the year. On the other hand, some employers ask their employees to take vacation off at a fixed period of the year. 

While vacation days are of extreme importance, many employees don’t consume them entirely. 

Therefore, employers must decide whether to create a policy allowing them to roll over the remaining vacation time days to the next year. These vacation time policies allow all staff members to plan accordingly.

Is PTO the Same As Vacation Time?

Although PTO and vacation time are used similarly by employees, there are key differences between the two.

Technically, vacation time is considered paid time off because the employer pays the employee who takes a relaxing holiday away from work. However, when an employee takes sick time or needs to address their mental health, that is also considered paid time off, but not vacation time.

Vacation time allows employees to avoid burnout, spend quality time with friends and family, and rejuvenate their working spirit. Conversely, paid time off encompasses other non-vacation days when an employee cannot work due to personal reasons, sickness, jury duty, emergencies, etc.

While the company’s paid time off policy includes vacation days, they are marked separately on the yearly calendar.

Paid time off is a comprehensive term for all types of paid leave, including vacation time. In paid time off, employees can select a specific reason for their absence from work, and no further details are typically required.

Small businesses can streamline their paid time off policies by providing a template for time off requests and implementing efficient time tracking systems like Buddy Punch. 

Understanding state laws and federal mandates regarding accrued PTO and unused time is crucial for creating an employee handbook that clearly outlines employee benefits and the amount of PTO available to full-time employees. 

Effective onboarding processes should educate employees about the type of time they can take off and how to request it, ensuring compliance with federal and state regulations while promoting a healthy work-life balance.

PTO Vs. Vacation Days | Differences

Let’s explore the differences between PTO and vacation days in more detail.

1. Time-off Limitations

Companies can set up rules regarding the limitations of vacation time off and paid time off. 

For paid time off, employers decide how many days fall into which category. For example, a company may choose to give ten sick leaves, five personal leaves, three bereavement leaves, and so on. 

Most of the PTO has to be pre-informed, except for emergencies and sick days.

As for the vacation days, companies can decide when a new employee is eligible for the vacation leave. Employers can also alot a fixed time of the year for an employee to take this time off. Furthermore, they can allow or deny the request for genuine reasons. 

2. Time-off Reasons

Paid time off days generally require an employee to fill out the reasons form and specify the reasons for their absence. For instance, in the case of sick leave, an employee is asked to submit a proper medical form or a doctor’s note. This helps the HR department minimize undue staff leave. 

Also, in the case of parental leave, the company expects employees to provide the required documentation. 

On the other hand, as the name suggests, vacation time off is for a stress-free holiday. 

There is no other reason than pure joy and fun. However, suppose an employee has consumed all of their sick leaves. In that case, they can compensate for extra sick leaves during vacation time off. 

3. Unused PTO Payout

Many companies offer unused PTO payouts. However, this generally does not apply to sick or casual leaves; only vacation days are entitled to PTO payouts. 

Companies are implementing three processes to ensure the right consumption of the leftover leaves. They can put a cap, do a rollover PTO, or have a “use it or lose it” plan.

Nevertheless, there are still times when few leaves are left unused. 

In such a scenario, if an employee quits the company or the company decides to lay off that employee, the employer pays the paid time off in cash. Hence, people refer to it as “cash in payout.”

How To Track PTO and Vacation Leaves?

Tracking PTO hours and vacation leaves is essential for businesses to comply with federal law and ensure accurate time tracking for their employees. 

Buddy Punch offers a comprehensive solution for managing PTO tracking, allowing businesses to easily monitor employees’ paid vacation days, PTO hours, and even unlimited vacation policies. 

With Buddy Punch, businesses can streamline their time tracking processes, ensuring that employees receive the correct number of days of PTO according to company policy and federal law. 

By efficiently managing PTO tracking, businesses can promote the well-being of their employees while staying compliant with regulations. 

Buddy Punch simplifies PTO management for US-based American businesses, helping them focus on their core operations.

Types of PTO (Paid Time Off)

Following are the different types of PTO you should familiarize yourself with.

1. Personal Time

There are various reasons for taking personal time PTO. It depends upon the situation of an employee. 

For example, employees can use them for doctor’s appointments and checkups, parent-teacher meetings, family emergencies, etc. 

Personal time is slightly different than sick and vacation PTO. However, just like a sick PTO, it is not necessary to apply it in advance in case of family emergencies, etc. 

2. Paid Sick Leave

Falling sick is not in the control of any human being. Therefore, all HR paid time off policies usually include paid ill leaves. 

Unpaid sick leaves for any injured person can be an added stress. Hence, staying home and relaxing while recovering can bring the employee back to the office sooner. 

On the other hand, from an employer’s perspective, floating viruses or germs from sick employees in the office is highly discouraged. Consequently, giving a sick staff break from work will ensure the safety of other employees.

3. Bereavement Leave

Showing compassion to your employee is essential to retain your employees. It creates a respectful space in the heart of your employees. 

Some companies use another term for bereavement paid leaves: funeral paid leaves. 

The number of days off for a death in the family depends on multiple factors, including the relationship with the deceased, time and distance to travel, etc. 

However, employers can ask for proof of death in some cases. Moreover, some companies are allowing grieving parents, for their loss of a newborn, stillbirth, or miscarriage, to take bereavement paid leaves.

4. Holidays

Holiday paid leaves refer to the public holidays announced by the federal government or state. Hence, these dates can vary accordingly. 

Holiday days include cultural, religious, and patriotic days in your country. A few examples of employees residing in the USA are Independence Day, Christmas, New Year’s Day, Memorial Day, Thanksgiving Day, and so on and so forth. 

Nevertheless, some organizations must stay open during the holiday season. They include hospitals, emergency services, firefighting departments, etc. 

Consequently, these organizations offer to pay overtime to their staff on duty or compensate them with floating days.

5. Floating Leave

As the name suggests, floating leaves are paid time off days without a fixed date. An employee can select any particular day for a leave. 

As we have discussed above, some organizations require a minimum staff to stay working during holidays. Those employees who work on a day off are offered floating leave. 

It is also very helpful for people who celebrate their religious festivals, which are not covered by the company. The moveable date option provides an employee with a healthy work-life balance.

6. Jury Duty

It is very important to help the community build a safe environment for everyone. Therefore, a court can summon an employee to present themselves as a juror on a specified date or dates. 

It is mandatory for them to go there and perform a juror’s duty as an upstanding citizen. Hence, the employer is expected to accept the employee’s jury duty leave. 

Nevertheless, an employer may ask for a court letter or a piece of proof.

Are PTO and Vacation Leave Mandatory?

Paid time off and vacation leaves are not mandatory in the USA. However, these leaves are encouraged for an employee’s ease and retention. 

Employees feel comfortable and relaxed knowing their job is secure and the company cares for its staff. These feelings stimulate the spirit of hard work and dedication. 

To avoid employee burnout, companies are increasingly including these time offs in their policies. 

Furthermore, providing PTO and vacation leaves results in a better work environment, yielding high-quality employee performance. 

Advantages and Disadvantages of a PTO Policy

Like any other company policy, there are some advantages and disadvantages associated with PTO. Let’s discuss them one by one.

Advantages of PTO Policy

Here are the top advantages of having a balanced PTO policy.

1. Flexibility for Employees

A sense of autonomy and openness can change the working attitude of a hardworking employee. 

Employees feel flexible and relaxed when it comes to PTOs. They don’t have to seek permission to take a day off in case of an emergency or sickness. Instead, they feel empowered to choose the day off without worrying about job security and pay deductions. 

PTOs send a direct message to all employees that the company understands their needs.

2. Honest Employee/Employer Relationship

Trust is the building block for any organization. Therefore, a mutual, honest bond between employees and their employers is crucial. 

Before PTO, employees were unsure about telling the truth to their bosses. Most of the time, they avoid telling their employers why they are taking a day off. 

For this reason, companies have started to implement PTO policies. It eliminates the need for argumentation and distrust. 

Moreover, such policies sow the seeds of transparency in employee and employer relationships. With specified paid time off, employees can take their time off as per their needs. 

3. Oppose to Separate Tracking Leaves

One advantage of a Paid Time Off (PTO) policy is that it simplifies leave tracking for both employees and employers.

With a PTO policy, employees have a single pool of leave days that they can use for vacation, being sick, personal days, or public holidays. This means they don’t have to keep track of different types of leave separately, which makes things easier for everyone.

3. More Work-Life Balance

The balance between personal and career life is key to a nourishing work environment. Nowadays, to boost productivity and efficiency, companies implement PTO policies. It ensures an employee has time for self-care, personal growth, and family values. 

The occasional breaks from work and prioritizing family time keep employees mentally stress-free and physically healthy as they are more fulfilled and refreshed. 

Hence, the employee’s performance shoots up which in turn uplifts company profits.

4. Less Administration Required

A general PTO policy becomes less hefty and more manageable for the managers or HR. It eliminates the need to fill out unnecessary paperwork, consequently reducing the workload. 

Similarly, it is easier for companies to use software like Buddy Punch to manage an employee’s time because of a single leave bracket. Other valuable tasks usually overburden the HR team. 

Therefore, a single PTO policy increases their time management efficiency. 

Furthermore, suppose a company has accrued a PTO carryover policy. In that case, it will add an extra workload while calculating the leave cash-ins at the beginning of the calendar year.

Disadvantages of a PTO Policy

While creating a PTO bank, policymakers should also keep a few disadvantages in mind.

1. Hoarding of Sick Leaves

Some employees confuse paid time off with vacation time off. Consequently, they end up not using their leaves even when needed. 

For example, a sick employee may come to the workplace in order to save their remaining leave and go on vacation at a planned time. 

Staying at home when feeling under the weather is of utmost importance because it may affect other employees, too. 

Imagine sitting beside a coughing colleague who was sick with the flu all day. It can have an unfavorable impact on other employees who are not ill.

2. Pay More by The Company

Some companies have a policy of paying out remaining vacation time off to employees who are either leaving the company or simply asking to cash in at the new year. This rule applies to vacation leaves only. 

However, in the general PTO policy, it is harder to differentiate between sick leave and vacation leave. Consequently, employers end up paying more to the employee.  

3. Employees Get Fewer Days Off

Nowadays, people look forward to working for companies offering more time off, like a traditional leave policy. 

However, under general PTO policy, an average employee may get up to 17 days off. This can be why a potential candidate may avoid getting on board with your company. 

Is Unlimited PTO a Good Idea for Companies?

Imagine having an unlimited cap on paid leaves and taking days off whenever required. Leading companies floated this idea to attract the top cream of candidates. However, this is now becoming a common practice in general organizations, too. 

Such policies encourage employees to enjoy the perks of staying loyal to their companies and be more productive. 

Employees who want to take a day off can simply request their superiors. If that request is approved, no one will ask further questions. Unlimited PTOs create a stronger bond between employees and employers, which benefits the company.

While no PTO capping seems attractive and lucrative, the reality is often different. No, it is not because of the overuse or misuse of the policy; it is the other way around. 

Surprisingly, employees underuse unlimited PTO. The main reasons are the company culture and workload. 

Because of the undefined boundaries of time off, employees rely on the work environment to define it. Due to constant deadlines and work overload, employees need to fully enjoy the leverage provided by the company. 

Some companies with strong HR controls keep a good check and balance on a healthy employee day off. 

HR people ask stressed-out employees to take a day off and safeguard their health from further deterioration.

Why Offer Separate Vacation Leave?

The most straightforward answer to this question is the system’s transparency. Scroll on to read more details.

1. PTO Payouts

It may not seem critical, but it is a key to a simplified payout policy. 

The majority of companies have a payout policy penned down in their systems. Therefore, the company must create a set of PTO silos to differentiate between vacation time off and other time off. 

When employees sail to another ship, their remaining vacation leaves are also cashed in the final financial settlements. If vacation leaves are not separated, how will an HR person separate leftover sick and vacation leaves?

This innocent change can bring massive ease in administrative work and reduce payouts by companies.

2. Avoids Encouraging Presenteeism

Yes, there is a thing called presenteeism. In cases where general PTO is set and no separate vacation leaves are defined, some people like to stack up all leaves and use them on their vacation days. 

The idea itself is only harmful once it is for those who are sick yet choose to be present in the office. 

Offices are usually built in confined spaces, and seatings are generally close to one another—chances of more people falling sick increase when one ill person sits in the room. 

In order to save up more leaves, injured or ill people keep coming to offices till their strength allows. It is recommended that vacation and other PTO leaves be kept separate to avoid such scenarios.

3. Perceived Fairness

Several employees find it unfair to have a general PTO. 

An employee with a sick family member to take care of can potentially use up all of their paid time off—leaving behind nothing to enjoy for vacation or relaxation. 

On the contrary, another employee who doesn’t have a dependent can use all of their general PTO on vacation. 

It sets a negative emotion among colleagues and certain jealousy factors. Therefore, companies who like to play fair in their organizations use separate silos for vacation leaves.

PTO Policy Best Practices for Your Company

Companies are adapting four typical PTO policies. You can choose the most suitable plan for your company to intrigue the interest of potential applicants.

1. PTO Accrual

In the accrual PTO policy, employees earn their paid days off. Employees get one paid time off day for a number of days or hours an employee works. 

The criteria for setting the number of days depends on the company and its policies. 

Some employers allow their employees to accrue every quarter, and others will enable them to accrue monthly. However, these PTOs cannot be rolled over to next year. The reason is that there is not a fixed number of leaves.

2. Fixed PTO

Fixed PTO policy is genuinely straightforward. It is the annual allocation of a fixed number of days at the beginning of the calendar year. It separates all categories within PTO, such as sick, parental, bereavement, etc. 

Employees can use these PTOs as per requirement throughout the year. 

Some employees can dry up the entire pool within a year without a carryover policy. However, if the company has a rollover policy, all unused leaves will be added to the pool of leaves next year. 

One of the benefits of this lump sum PTO allotment is that employees have an explicit knowledge of remaining paid time off. 

3. Unlimited PTO

The whole idea of curating such a plan was to attract high-class employees with a perk of unlimited paid leaves. It instills in employees a sense of liberty and autonomy to decide when and how much they take the PTO. 

Without any capping, it virtually broadens the canvas of responsibility, and employees take their work time more seriously.

They must meet their deadlines and accomplish their target goals to avail themselves of their unlimited time off. 

Furthermore, apart from the above reasons, the team should be fine with an employee’s absence. 

4. Bank PTO

The bank of PTO is almost the same as that of fixed PTO. Except that there are no separate categories. 

Employees receive a complete pool of leaves at the beginning of their session. It is then up to the employee to use those leaves however they wish. 

Employees who want to take a day off for any reason don’t need to give any reason to managers. Bank PTO is free from buckets in the form of vacation, sick, personal, etc. 

Which is Better Consolidated or Separate Leave Plans?

When a company decides to put together a time off policy, it must carefully understand the concepts of consolidated and separate leave plans. Each plan has its benefits and drawbacks. 

Hence, it is recommended that complete research is done beforehand since multiple components are involved for an individual company.

Keeping all leaves in a single combined pool can cause added responsibility on the administrative team while compiling the financial settlements when an employee leaves the company. 

On the other hand, a separate silo can help identify the vacation leaves and other PTOs. 

A single pool of leaves can cause an extra payout. Similarly, at the end of every year, vacation leaves are allowed to roll over next year. All unused PTO other than vacations is carried over with consolidated leaves. 

Separate leave plans are more accessible to track for a company that wants to know how many sick leaves an employee has taken. Nevertheless, some companies find it effortless to track combined leaves and want to avoid seeing why an employee was on leave and don’t worry about carryover. 

According to paid time off laws, companies are not required to provide personal or vacation leaves to part-time/ temporary employees. However, employers may have to grant all leaves in the consolidated leave plan. 

For a separate leave plan, HR has to make two separate plans: one for permanent and another for temporary employees.

How to Make a Custom PTO Strategy?

Curating a perfect PTO strategy is vital for an organization and its employee’s growth. The more flexible it is, the more employees will feel appreciated. Similarly, that plan should be smooth and hassle-free for the administration. 

Several factors should be deliberated when developing such strategies.

1. Aggregate or Accrual System

Companies must know the difference between giving lump sum and accrual leaves. Some employers find it better to pass on the complete pool of leaves at the beginning of the year. 

However, others find it appropriate for the employees to earn their leave by the number of hours/days they work. 

2. Carryover or Yearly System

Employers must decide at the end of the year if any unused leave should be rolled over to next year or not. 

Many companies motivate their employees to use up all their remaining leaves; otherwise, they will not be compensated next year.

3. Combined or Separate Leaves

Choose the best-suited strategy for your organization from combined or separate PTO plans. 

The flexibility given in the merged leave plans mostly suits the employee. In comparison, employers may like to have a lesser workload by utilizing a separate leave plan.

4. Reimbursement System

Some employers offer employees to cash in remaining leaves. However, this may lead to employee presenteeism. Such policies benefit employees who have worked hard to pocket the benefits.

5. Competitive Cultural Norms

The company policy sometimes looks attractive on paper. However, it does not suit the culture of the company. Hence, it doesn’t work out. 

Therefore, keep your work environment in mind. 

For instance, unlimited PTO may seem appealing to the employee. However, your employee may be unable to avail of the opportunity in full.

How to Accrue/Calculate PTO and Vacation Time?

Calculating PTO and vacation time may depend on how frequently time off is provided to the employee. The number of hours and days an employee works can determine the vacation/PTO days. 

There are specific ways you can accrue these days, such as hourly, daily, biweekly, yearly, etc. 

Some of these methods can be simple, while others can be complex. Therefore, different businesses opt for the best one that suits them individually.

1. Hourly

PTO accrued based on the number of hours worked.

Formula: PTO Accrued = Hours Worked × Accrual Rate

Example: If an employee works 40 hours per week and the accrual rate is 0.038 hours per hour worked, then PTO accrued per week would be 40 hours × 0.038 = 1.52 hours.

2. Daily

PTO accrued based on the number of days worked.

Formula: PTO Accrued = Days Worked × Accrual Rate

Example: If an employee works 5 days per week and the accrual rate is 0.5 days per day worked, then PTO accrued per week would be 5 days × 0.5 = 2.5 days.

3. Biweekly

PTO accrued every two weeks.

Formula: PTO Accrued = Hours Worked × Accrual Rate

Example: If an employee works 80 hours over two weeks and the accrual rate is 0.076 hours per hour worked, then PTO accrued per two weeks would be 80 hours × 0.076 = 6.08 hours.

4. Semimonthly

PTO accrued twice a month.

Formula: PTO Accrued = Hours Worked × Accrual Rate

Example: If an employee works 86.67 hours in the first half of the month and the accrual rate is 0.046 hours per hour worked, then PTO accrued for the first half of the month would be 86.67 hours × 0.046 = 3.99 hours.

5. Monthly

PTO accrues once a month.

Formula: PTO Accrued = Hours Worked × Accrual Rate

Example: If an employee works 173.33 hours in a month and the accrual rate is 0.076 hours per hour worked, then PTO accrued for the month would be 173.33 hours × 0.076 = 13.17 hours.

6. Yearly

PTO accrued annually.

Formula: PTO Accrued = Hours Worked × Accrual Rate

Example: If an employee works 2080 hours in a year and the accrual rate is 0.076 hours per hour worked, then PTO accrued for the year would be 2080 hours × 0.076 = 158.08 hours.

How To Use Paid Time Off and Vacation Days? Tips For Employees

Vacation days and PTO are often underutilized by employees. There are certain things an employee must keep in mind to use this perk fully.

1. Plan Your Vacations In Advance

Experts recommend to plan and book your vacation time off ahead of time. 

Let’s assume you want to travel to a warm country in January to relax and sunbathe. It will be better to plan beforehand so that you know when not to schedule your weekly meetings and travel days. 

Planning also helps avoid too many employees leaving at the same time. 

For example, you decide to take a break from work at the last minute. However, your associate is already going to the Bahamas; there is a high chance you will not be granted leave.

2. Your Manager Knows

Always inform your line manager as soon as you plan your vacation. It gives a heads-up to your boss about when not to expect you in the office. 

Going on a vacation without informing your manager is discouraged and is not a healthy approach in a professional environment. You can request to be assigned tasks in advance to have plenty of time to complete them. 

Informing your manager before making the official request is a courteous thing. 

It increases the mutual level of trust and respect. This practice leads to discussion and finding solutions to how your team will manage stuff behind you.

3. Take Advantage Of Paid Holidays

Some employees feel guilty about leaving work behind and going on a leisure trip. However, they must understand that paid vacation off is part of company policy. 

HR has induced these holidays to help employees get a timeout from daily work stress. Being punctual and working hard can take a toll on a person. 

Therefore, a planned paid holiday recharges the energy. Taking a paid holiday is a sign of self-care and ensures you bring the best of yourself at work.

FAQs